An Ugly Side of Home Inspection

True story.

While conducting a home inspection on a particularly large property in Kalamazoo County, a local real estate agent decided to engage in some small talk. About home inspectors. It turns out that this particular real estate agent lives in the same neighborhood as a local home inspector. His opening comment was that this particular home inspector living nearby "likes to engage in politics."

"Politics?" I asked. Yes, politics, apparently. Or at the least, unethical business practices.

As the story was related, the neighborhood home inspector had a friend--who happened to be another home inspector--who wanted to purchase a house. The house was apparently too costly, so the home inspectors entered into an unwritten agreement that the neighborhood home inspector would inspect the house for the other inspector, documenting problems and deficiencies that did not exist, and exaggerating the problems that actually did exist. Thus the home inspector wanting to buy the house in question would be able to ask for reductions in the sale price. It was not revealed whether or not the property actually sold.

The truthfulness of this story could not be verified, but it would seem that this particular real estate agent had little or nothing to gain by relating this story to me. This story is not shared to point fingers at anyone. It is shared to illustrate yet another reason that home inspectors should be licensed in Michigan.

It is unknown whether the inspectors involved are members of any home inspection association, or whether any association they may subscribe to has any code of ethics, nor whether this particular real estate agent reported the inspectors involved to any association. Some might suggest that the real estate agent may have been sharing this story out of frustration that nothing could be done about the home inspectors in question, and that might be a valid point. Historically, home inspector associations have not made disciplinary records available to the public, so it is difficult to ascertain what associations do take action on complaints.

Though it is likely too late for the Michigan House to act, House Bill 4014 (2011) would license home inspectors in Michigan. Introduced by Democrat Richard LeBlanc, HB 4014 has been held captive by the House Regulatory Reform Committee (Hugh Crawford, Chair). A recent conversation with Representative Crawford's office will shed some light on some possible reasons why the committee chairman has neglected to bring this very important legislation to the committee's attention.

Slate Roofing

A caller several weeks ago inquired about inspecting a home with a slate roof.  The caller had been told by previous home inspectors that she had contacted that a separate inspection was necessary, and that it needed to be performed by a specialist in slate roofing.  She evidently had bought this suggestion hook, line, and sinker.

The truth is, any competent home inspector should be able to inspect a slate roof.  In this particular circumstance, the roof appeared to be an artificial, or manufactured, slate roof.  The roof shingles likely contained asbestos, based on the age and appearance of the shingles, and the rear of the house had been re-roofed using laminated asphalt shingles.

Slate roofs are not difficult to inspect if the home inspector is competent and knowledgeable regarding slate and manufactured slate roofs.  The inspection process itself is very similar to the inspection of any other type of roof; investigating for signs of damage or leaks, looking for missing or loose shingles, investigating for signs of improper installation or alteration, and so forth.

If a home inspector is properly trained, there should be no need for an additional roof inspection during the home inspection process.  The roof should be inspected as part of any competent home inspection.  Substantive training in home inspection will include slate roofing, so a good home inspector will be able to inspect and report on the condition of a typical slate roof.